Fire Emblem I drew the three FE3H lords as students! (OC) |
- I drew the three FE3H lords as students! (OC)
- Erika and Seth, only they're from a 1996 Sega Saturn JRPG.
- Prepare yourself for the Gatekeeper ultimate form!
- Chrom: Risen King Upscaled PNG cutout
- Boba Hilda
- |REQ| Morgan and Anna Bonding Time by JDRider
- A Day on the Life of Heroes - No Disarm, No Harm
- Those Two Agarthans [12] - "Choose Your Legend"
- Congrats to miss Marianne!! (OC)
- Marianne deserves the world! CYL5 1st Place Winner~ (OC)
- Marianne von Edmund... as a Flier! Congratulations for her victory in CYL 5!
- [OC] I tried to draw Marianne as a dancer!
- My Fire Emblem Favs A-Z (feel free to judge my bad taste)
- shittymarthonicle.png
- The Daily Life of My 10 Merged Marth #1 - 10
- Happy Hilda Day! (OC)
- [Art] Our path (Edelgard and Dimitri)
- A deep dive into Crimson Flower's military campaign
- I drew Mitama and Caeldori ✨
- It happened lads
- So uh, how bout that CYL?
- f!grima commission i did for a friend:)!
- Made Edelgard dressed as tall vampire lady, no idea what I was doing.
- To celebrate the 4th Anniversary of Fire Emblem: Heroes, here is my Fire Emblem corner in my room! Thank you Fire Emblem for all the fun memories!
I drew the three FE3H lords as students! (OC) Posted: 02 Feb 2021 01:18 PM PST
| ||
Erika and Seth, only they're from a 1996 Sega Saturn JRPG. Posted: 02 Feb 2021 09:54 AM PST
| ||
Prepare yourself for the Gatekeeper ultimate form! Posted: 02 Feb 2021 04:30 AM PST
| ||
Chrom: Risen King Upscaled PNG cutout Posted: 02 Feb 2021 12:22 PM PST
| ||
Posted: 02 Feb 2021 01:25 PM PST
| ||
|REQ| Morgan and Anna Bonding Time by JDRider Posted: 02 Feb 2021 02:27 PM PST
| ||
A Day on the Life of Heroes - No Disarm, No Harm Posted: 02 Feb 2021 07:03 PM PST
| ||
Those Two Agarthans [12] - "Choose Your Legend" Posted: 02 Feb 2021 01:00 PM PST
| ||
Congrats to miss Marianne!! (OC) Posted: 01 Feb 2021 08:57 PM PST
| ||
Marianne deserves the world! CYL5 1st Place Winner~ (OC) Posted: 02 Feb 2021 04:43 AM PST
| ||
Marianne von Edmund... as a Flier! Congratulations for her victory in CYL 5! Posted: 02 Feb 2021 01:54 PM PST
| ||
[OC] I tried to draw Marianne as a dancer! Posted: 02 Feb 2021 04:08 PM PST
| ||
My Fire Emblem Favs A-Z (feel free to judge my bad taste) Posted: 02 Feb 2021 08:49 PM PST
| ||
Posted: 02 Feb 2021 03:23 PM PST
| ||
The Daily Life of My 10 Merged Marth #1 - 10 Posted: 02 Feb 2021 02:44 PM PST
| ||
Posted: 02 Feb 2021 08:16 PM PST
| ||
[Art] Our path (Edelgard and Dimitri) Posted: 02 Feb 2021 05:31 PM PST
| ||
A deep dive into Crimson Flower's military campaign Posted: 02 Feb 2021 07:53 PM PST IntroductionCrimson Flower is often criticized for many reasons. One of the reasons it is criticized for is that the military campaign is too one-sided and Edelgard owns her enemies too easily making her opposition too weak. I disagree and believe her opponents are more competent than people let on and hopefully this post will try to convince you of why. Edelgard does win rather quickly but this has to do with her having a really strong army, Byleth support, as well as being very clever and having another smart tactician as opposed to plot convenience making her opposition incompetent. State of war during timeskipFirst of all, there is a dumb criticism of Edelgard that I want to address. This is to do with her being incompetent without Byleth because she made no major gains in the five year war. While the Imperial Army is the strongest military individually, they are up against a united front between the Church of Seiros and the Kingdom of Faerghus who rival them.
The Knights of Seiros may be small in number but as far as quality fighters go, it surpasses the Empire's.
Also, the Church of Seiros is still very strong in Crimson Flower compared to the other routes.
The same should be true of Faerghus' knights who are taught to fight before reading and writing. Strength is the biggest value in Faerghus so the average citizen of Faerghus is more likely to be fit for military service which implies that the Empire having a larger population isn't as big of an advantage as it may seem.
Furthermore, in AM, when the Empire was numerically superior, Rodrigue did say that the Kingdom's forces are elite, thus implying they are on average stronger than the Empire ones but not enough to compensate for the Empire's military superiority.
In AM, where only the Eastern parts of Faerghus were free, Dimitri still managed to invade the Empire with an army that is half as numerous as the Empire's so I can see a united Kingdom and Church of Seiros having a military that has similar man power compared to the Empire. Here is proof that the Kingdom army was half as numerous as the Empire. Gilbert says that the Empire has more than double the number that the Kingdom has but this is before getting the help of Charon.
After getting help from Charon and the Alliance, their numbers now rival the Empire.
Conversely in Verdant Wind, the Alliance only has half as many men as the Empire, so do the math and you get that a fractured Kingdom is able to match it.
Also, Edelgard suddenly going on the offensive when Byleth comes back is a great strategic move because they are a great morale booster which can help in making rapid advances. Also, Byleth's return would be devastating for Edelgard's opponents who would also be caught off guard by the sudden offensive when they only had to deal with a stalemate for 5 whole years.
Finally, during the 5 year timeskip, the Empire managed to seize much of Western Faerghus while losing no territory of its own. Thus it stands to reason that while the war was at a stalemate, Edelgard was still slowly winning it even without Byleth's support.
All in all, assuming Edelgard is incompetent without Byleth is completely baseless. Great Bridge attackClaude was proactive enough to send Judith and her men to the Great Bridge. This is a clever move on his part because he knows how Gloucester is pro Empire so by sending his loyalists to the bridge, he prevents the Empire and the pro Imperial Alliance from linking up more formally, establishing trade and military ties, etc.
...........................................
Edelgard made it a goal to kill Judith and force her army to surrender creating a power vacuum in Daphnel allowing her to seize it immediately afterwards.
Claude anticipated Edelgard's strategy and told Judith to retreat if she's ever in danger which would have allowed him to continue to hold on to Daphnel.
Unfortunately for Claude, Judith was too stubborn and attempted to retreat when it was too late.
Although Judith did try to retreat after it was clear she would lose so it's not like she was incompetent but simply got overwhelmed. Most bosses stubbornly stick to their position and not retreat which goes to show how Edelgard's opponents are rather competent than the average opponents of other lords.
If Judith successfully followed through Claude's instructions, the Empire's strategy would have been foiled.
Furthermore, while Edelgard predicted Claude would send reinforcements, she underestimated how fast they would arrive so she did fail in her initial objective of securing the bridge before reinforcements arrived. Furthermore, she didn't properly predict how quickly Claude would react, which goes to show while she can read her opponents, she has some difficulty reading Claude.
Assault on DerdriuClaude's first act is to prevent the civilian population from leaving the city showing he's a morally grey schemer.
This is the same tactic that Edelgard uses in Enbar so there's an obvious parallel between the two which is why neither Edelgard or Claude end up condemning the other for it.
Edelgard managed to foil this strategy by taking over the gates that Claude had blockaded. These gates were full of Alliance troops so taking them prevented Alliance reinforcements too.
When Edelgard starts attacking Derdriu, Claude ends up flanking her army with Almyran troops. She was caught completely off guard which goes to show she can't really predict him. It is quite unpredictable because the Almyrans are feared by the Alliance and Claude's heritage is a secret.
An oft-repeated criticism of the military campaign against the Alliance is that it happens too quickly and Claude ends up turning into a joke due to how quickly he loses. I disagree with this take because as I've shown below, even when united, the Alliance is half as strong as the Empire in terms of manpower as shown in Verdant Wind.
Right now the anti Imperial Alliance is half as strong considering how the pro and anti Imperial forces within the Alliance are roughly equal in strength. Therefore, the Imperial army may very well be 4 times as stronger than the Alliance army.
Finally, its not like Claude is ideologically opposed to Edelgard so him guaranteeing its safety in Edelgard's hands isn't a major loss especially when he can simply return to Almyra so I don't see how Claude got screwed in CF anymore than the other non VW routes.
Defense of Garreg MachAfter taking the Alliance, the main body of the Imperial Army moves to the Alliance in preparation to attack the Kingdom.
This made it the perfect opportunity for the Church of Seiros to launch an attack on Garreg Mach because the Imperial Army is now more spread out. The Church of Seiros uses Rhea's army to engage the Imperial army. This is done as a diversion so that another force can infiltrate the monastery.
Edelgard and Hubert deduce that the Church of Seiros will have an advantage due to knowing the terrain and secrets very well.
Certainly, the Church of Seiros uses the forest to hide troops in such as Flayn. They also utilize fire to create an opening in order to create another breach point. Enemy Phase Two
Enemy Phase Twelve
While the Empire managed to repel the expeditionary force that tried to take the monastery, the Imperial Army fighting Rhea and Catherine's army ended up getting decimated. The decimation of the army was so bad that Randolph and Ladislava, both highly respected Imperial generals, end up dying.
....................................................................
I like how in CF, you end up losing two highly ranked members of the army. Compare that to the other routes where you don't really lose anyone on your side after time-skip as a result of a battle. ArianrhodEdelgard tried to get House Rowe to defect so that the Empire can seize Arianrhod without a fight. Her plan was foiled by Rodrigue entering the city and taking charge which shows how Rodrigue is quite intelligent and proactive in foiling any attempts at betrayal. Makes sense as he is known as the Shield of Faerghus and proves his title by defending the loyalist portion of the Kingdom from the combined strength of the Empire and Dukedom.
Anyhow a month later, Edelgard concocts another scheme to take Arianrhod. Basically she spreads the information to her entire army to prepare for an assault on Fhirdiad while in reality preparing to take Arianrhod instead.
Edelgard's strategy allowed her to fool Rodrigue into sending some of his troops to the capital. It exploits Rodrigue's loyalty to Dimitri as he is certainly going to make sure Dimitri is safe. It also exploits Cornelia's arrogance, who was sure that TWSITD have Edelgard under their control.
With this move, Edelgard managed to play Cornelia like a puppet, the same individual who plays Faerghus like a puppet.
Of course, Arundel saw through Edelgard's ploy and punished her for it by destroying Arianrhod, causing a huge amount of casualties in Edelgard's army as well as her new allies.
Edelgard managed to turn around the bad situation with a propaganda coup boosting morale in her army. She kills two birds with one stone, inspires hatred in the army for the Church as they hadn't overtly done any atrocities up to this point and also hides the fact there is internal friction within the Empire.
Considering how there is a legend about the pillars of light being from the goddess, linking the church to it makes even more sense than you one would think.
Edelgard truly is the lady of deceit. Tailtean PlainsRight after Rodrigue was killed, the Empire attacks Fraldarius, taking advantage of his death for an easy victory.
By taking Fraldarius, Edelgard aims to launch an attack on Fhirdiad from both the South and East.
Dimitri shows his strategic prowess in CF, unlike when he's a boar in the other routes. He realizes that allowing the Empire to lay siege to Fhirdiad would be a bad idea and instead prepares to meet the Empire on the Tailtean Plains. He concocts a strategy where the Knights of Seiros will flank the Empire while the Empire is busy with the Kingdom army.
Edelgard managed to deduce the fact that Dimitri will try to intercept her for both strategic reasons as well as a historical one showing how well she's at reading her opponents, even more so than Hubert. It also shows she's good at finding multiple reasons to explain her prediction.
Anyhow, Dimitri shows that he's quite deceptive and was in fact planning to get the church to engage the Imperial army first, not the other way around like he told Seiros.
Edelgard deduces that Dimitri is planning to use the church and realizes that the weather is preventing the two from coordinating.
Hubert tells the Imperial army to prepare for an attempt at a flank.
Dedue shows proactive thinking by giving some soldiers crests to transform into beasts without telling Dimitri about his plan. It's a similar last resort to Edelgard at the end of AM. Even Hubert was taken by surprise. Also, the fact that Dedue didn't tell Dimitri shows that Dedue understood that his liege would never accept such a strategy being employed which goes to show how perceptive he is.
Dedue was also smart enough to command the soldiers to transform in phases which means not to transform all at once. This puts uncertainty in even Hubert and makes the Empire more prone to making rash decisions due to having to kill soldiers quickly to avoid having them transform.
The Kingdom is still sending its own reinforcements from Gautier territory which shows it is putting its all and even Edelgard feels there's a possibility that the Empire can get overwhelmed if they don't defeat the Kingdom generals quickly.
After Dimitri's death, the Kingdom army is in chaos which Rhea exploits by having them act as a distraction so that her own knights can retreat back to Fhirdiad. She also keeps morale in her knights by invoking the goddess showing how even when things become tough, she can still keep order. Rhea using Dimitri's men as pawns for her own is an interesting role reversal to how Dimitri attempted to use the Knights of Seiros to preserve his own forces. Rhea basically ends up outplaying Dimitri in his own game.
.............................................
Attack on FhirdiadRhea's now desperate for revenge as her chances at outright winning her zero. Catherine suggests to flee Fodlan for the time being but at this point, Rhea is no longer interested in retreating.
Her plan is to set the capital on fire, making it hazardous for the Imperial army to fight in. This is also going to cause the Knights of Seiros to eventually perish as well but at this point, Rhea is willing to sacrifice everyone for the sake of revenge.
I don't really understand Rhea's logic in setting the capital on fire. The explanation is that it will prevent the Empire from bringing in large forces which is true and it did successfully prevent Edelgard from launching an all out assault on the capital from two directions.
However, what if Edelgard just decided to let the city burn and not have her army enter it? You could argue that Edelgard would not allow so many civilians to perish in the flames but why would Rhea think this? I suppose an argument could be made that Edelgard trying to avoid pointless deaths due to delaying her offensive is proof she would not allow civilians to burn.
But that could simply be because she wants to preserve her own forces which is more likely to be assumed by someone who hates Edelgard. Anyway, if you find any way to rationalize burning Fhirdiad being a strategically good move, please feel free to share your rationale. ConclusionOverall, I hope everyone has gained a better appreciation of the military campaign in CF. Sure it's short but a lot is happening on both sides of the conflict. On a final note, I would like to refute this notion of Edelgard being more competent on the other routes. People say that because Edelgard controls far more territory in the other routes, she's more competent. But that's mainly because of Cornelia's coup. She ends up on the losing streak once the actual route starts and never recovers. [link] [comments] | ||
Posted: 02 Feb 2021 11:21 AM PST
| ||
Posted: 02 Feb 2021 10:51 AM PST
| ||
Posted: 02 Feb 2021 08:58 AM PST
| ||
f!grima commission i did for a friend:)! Posted: 02 Feb 2021 03:27 AM PST
| ||
Made Edelgard dressed as tall vampire lady, no idea what I was doing. Posted: 02 Feb 2021 10:59 AM PST
| ||
Posted: 02 Feb 2021 09:17 PM PST
|
You are subscribed to email updates from Fire Emblem Fans Unite!. To stop receiving these emails, you may unsubscribe now. | Email delivery powered by Google |
Google, 1600 Amphitheatre Parkway, Mountain View, CA 94043, United States |
No comments:
Post a Comment